June 9, 2010

I Finally Need To Have MY Say

I read lots of blogs. Mainly adoptive and infertility blogs. Someone can say whatever he/she wants on a blog because well, it's his/her blog. I don't have to agree with a blog author all the time. And frankly, if I don't like what someone has to say repeatedly or once in a while if I find someone has a really hateful post, then I'll just stop reading a blog altogether.

I try not to get controversial on my blog because I like to keep things light. I really don't have the time or energy to deal with mean or ignorant comments. I focus on my relationship with my daughter (through the good times and the difficult times) rather than on any real controversial issues.

Lately, I have found a few blog posts that have made me wince a little, and a few others that have made me quite angry. And sometimes it is not even a blog post that angers me. Many times it is just ignorant and/or nasty comments that follow a blog post.

I am not going to link to any blogs for this post. I am just going to address a few subjects and my thoughts on them.

I read a blog post the other day (from an adult international adoptee perspective) that raising and loving a child that was not birthed from you is not natural. I'm sorry, but I completely, utterly disagree with this statement. I can say that the circumstances that led Briana and I to each other may not have been optimal. We will always wear the scars and bruises from our pasts. But our love for one another - it is COMPLETELY NATURAL. Did we have to learn to love one another? Sure. We were strangers at first. But now, our love is very, very deep and very, very natural. I would give my life up for my daughter. When she hurts, I hurt. I could not love her any more if I had given birth to her. When I found out I was pregnant back in March (sadly I miscarried), do you want to know what I thought? How can I possibly love the child I am carrying as much as I love my Briana? Deep down, I know I would have truly loved that child, but it is a thought that crossed my mind. Briana may not be my blood, but she is my soul.

I watched a music video on U*Tube the other day. It featured a really a beautiful song about infertility. People obviously entrenched in the throws of infertility were commenting on the song. And there were a few people that suggested/commented that those dealing with infertility should maybe consider adoption. A few of the infertile commenters stated that they wanted their "own" children and they didn't want an adopted child to feel like a consolation prize. I felt very sorry for them. They are very narrow-minded. Yes - when I was going through infertility treatments, I was trying to have a biological child to grow my family. But, I never closed my mind to adoption (obviously) as a possibility either. I just tried the biological route first. The route most familiar to me. And let me tell you something right now. Did I have to come to terms with my infertility? Absolutely. I won't lie. But know this - Briana was NEVER my consolation prize. Adoption was just a different path to parenthood. My daughter has filled my heart with so much happiness and joy, I don't feel like I missed out on anything. The only thing I sometimes feel like I "missed out" on was the "newborn phase" of life. And it pains me much, much more that I missed out on Briana's newborn phase of life than just experiencing the newborn phase of life of a child in general.

A few months back, I read a post by an adult international adoptee that did an entire rant on infertility - how adoption is just a "fix" for infertile parents and that adoptive children feel they are "second best" if they are adopted by infertile couples. It bothered me so much that I still think about it today. I'm sure she does not speak for every adopted person.

Now, I try to be open and listen to the voice of adult international adoptees (and domestic adoptees as well). I've learned and now understand that adult adoptees often believe their voices, opinions and experiences are not validated - especially by adoptive parents - because their experiences aren't always positive. It is definitely hard at times (and sometimes a little scary to be honest) to hear what they have to say, but I do listen to them because they have the experience and knowledge of what it is like to grow up as adoptees in transracial households and live as a minorities. This is something I never had to do. I've never walked a mile in their shoes, so I continue to listen to them so that I might know one day how Briana might feel. Hearing their stories are extremely helpful for me.

BUT, this particular adoptee has NEVER walked a mile in MY (infertile) shoes. She even stated that she has not experienced infertility herself. So, why did she address a subject that she has absolutely no experience in? This is something that I would never, ever do. I would never rant about adult international adoptees or their feelings because I have never walked in their shoes. I might disagree with what someone might say, but I would never be hateful. From what I understand of this person's upbringing from her blog, she has siblings that are the biological children of her parents. The impression I got from the adoptee was that her parents are/were not infertile. And she was being admittedly pretty nasty about the subject on her blog too. All I can say is that until you have lived as an infertile person, felt the emptiness and the pain, you have no right to speak on the subject. Her ignorance astounded me. This is one particular blog that I won't be returning to.

And as for Briana, I pray she never feels second best. I will always let her know she is number 1 in my heart. If this person believes that Briana was the "fix" for my infertility, well then maybe she is right. Briana mended my broken heart. And hopefully I mended hers. Was Briana never supposed to grow up with a family? Was she not allowed the right to know the love of a mother and a father? I personally think that is the right of every human being.

I know there are some people out there that wonder why I took Briana away from the country of her birth. As for Briana living in her country, that was probably never going to happen. Briana was in an orphanage accredited for international adoption. She could have possibly ended up in a country other than America if I had not been matched with her, but I'm pretty sure she wasn't going to live her life in China. That was the decision the orphanage and the CCAA made long before I ever came along. So if Briana was chosen to leave the country of her birth, then why not leave with me? Right?

I am...someone that will do everything in her power to help her daughter love the country of her birth. Someone that will be honest with her daughter about her adoption. Someone that will take in to account every single feeling her daughter has - the good and the bad. Someone that will never brush her daughter's feelings aside - validating each and every one. Someone that will cherish the day her daughter was placed in her arms and will commemorate it every single year. Someone that will understand, remember and honor what her daughter lost while also teaching her daughter to focus on all she has gained. Someone that will hold her daughter's hand when she comes across racism because she knows it will happen. Someone that will talk openly to her daughter about her birth parents and foster parents. Someone that will love her daughter unconditionally.

So, now I have addressed a lot of the things that have been bothering me in the blog world lately. I just needed to finally speak up and have MY say. I am not going to address these deep issues again for a while. I like keeping my blog light and happy. I don't want to be all preachy, and I never want to act like I'm some kind of expert in the adoption experience. I've only been an adoptive parent for 3 years. I'm no expert. I am still learning as I go along.

Just remember - never tell me my love for my daughter is not natural. Never tell me I think my daughter is "second best." Never, ever tell me my daughter is not "my own." I love my daughter with every fiber of my being. She is my life, she is my joy and she is my very REAL daughter.

5 Kind Words:

Christie said...

Girl...all I've got is AMEN

Lindsay said...

Your way of growing your family through adoption may have been 'second choice' but that never makes it second best. That you and Doug adore Briana, and she adores you too, is so obvious. Your love is real.

I feel baffled, rather than angry, at those who speak out against International Adoption. Would they rather these children grew up without a family; often denied proper education or health care? I didn't take Hannah's language and culture from her - that happened as soon as she was placed for adoption by her first mother. Does anyone seriously think an orphanage provides a child with a sense of pride and culutre? Would it have been better for Hannah to stay in her birth country instead of being adopted by a foreigner? I doubt it to be blunt, because the racism against Romani's is so, so extreme here (and growing) that she would have encountered horrific prejudice constantly all her life. And her chances of being adopted domestically were minute.

What is imperfect in this world is the fact that poverty means many people are unable to raise their children, or that there are social and political factors at work that lead to children being placed, abandoned or neglected. I think it is much more 'unnatural' to leave a baby in the care of a person who is violent and absolutely incapable of raising the child and giving them what they need and deserve to thrive and develop to their potential, than it is for another family to adopt them, cherish them and love them unconditionally.

I think the experience of growing up as a transracial adoptee a couple of decades ago will be very different from how it is today. I hope that, with the better knowledge and understanding we now have, our children will not feel the same sense of disconnection which some adult adoptees have.

My love for Hannah is not forced or unnatural. It is the most natural thing in the world. 'Love is gentle, love is kind. Love never fails.' Love is natural and it is a gift no matter how those we love came into our lives.

Anonymous said...

many years ago, I attended "Chinese Culture day" hosted by "Families with Children from China" in NY, I'll never forget what I witnessed. These Adoptive parents I have met made me believe "love is thicker than blood"... I have also met adult adoptees who ador their adoptive parents and told me so many wonderful stories about their adoptive parents...I could write a book about them.

I did see some negative comments wirtten by very nasty adoptees on youtube, I dont think their adoptive parents have anything to do with their bitterness, their situations could have been much worse without their adoptive families. some people have issues, and they blame others for their problems, if they were brought up by their bio parents, they'd blame them as well, just for different reasons.

Anonymous said...

Christina-
I am so sorry that you suffered abuse at the hands of your adoptive family. Sadly, many parents give birth to children every day and choose to repeat the cycle of abuse. Child abuse is absolutely tragic, whether committed by an adoptive or a biological family. I hope that somehow you can heal and perhaps advocate for others. I wish peace and happiness for you.

Lisa-
I am glad that you you posted this. I, too cringe when I read things like, "A child of our 'own', when referring to trying to conceive versus adoption. YIKES! It's hurtful. I think people who post such things just haven't gotten to a place where they are at peace with ALL of the beautiful, and equally valid ways to build a family. I belong to a message board (we all met on babycenter YEARS ago when we were trying Clomid!) and some of the adoptive moms have had to step in and help some of the members of our little group be more aware of how comments like that one can be hurtful and insensitive. Sometimes, you just need to make people aware. I am glad that you have taken this step and have spoken your mind here. Maybe you'll now have the fuel to be able to just put it out there when these types of things bother you. I know, sometimes you have to pick your battles, though.

I have NEVER thought of adoption as second best. There were just a LOT of hurdles in my way for a traditional adoption. So now, I am going to be able to give birth to my adopted child! Something I would have NEVER thought that this was even possible a year ago!

Joan said...

My two girls are also from China. From reading your blog all this time I know you get it. Your daughter's first family is unknown and may never be known. Due to the circumstances in China, babies are left without identifing information. Maybe some of the commenters are not aware of that fact. I know if it would be possible to find out who my daughters' first families are, I would do it and would love to be in contact with them. My girls ask about them now at the ages of 5 and 8 and I am doing all I can to help them cope. I know it will get harder for them as they get older. I will continue to help them and do whatever I can to let them know they matter to many people. I am sorry for the children (birth as well as adopted) that have been abused. That should never happen and I wish the people that abuse children and old people would just die a horrible death. But, that won't change the fact that adoptions happen. Some adoptions have alot known about the child's history and some don't. I hope and pray more information is available from China for all our children. I will continue to stay in touch with the adoption community for that one comment that will unlock the past for my girls. Thank you for your post!

Related Posts with Thumbnails